Midnight Marinara Suggestion Box

Hmmm, I think it will be interesting to see what Slimey and DP think of each others work.

I think it'd be funny if DP and I made a secret pact to be incredibly unfair and hyperbolic about each others' work.

DP is probably halfway there anyway on more than a few of mine, anyway. XD

I think it'd be funny if DP and I made a secret pact to be incredibly unfair and hyperbolic about each others' work.
DP is probably halfway there anyway on more than a few of mine, anyway. XD

If DP takes issue with any of your stories just whip out your sub count. jk.

I would love to hear a creepypasta debate between you two with David as the mediator. Just pick a story that one of you likes and the other hates and go all out on each other. Make a pact without David's knowledge and just completely blast the shit out of each other while David just sits their twiddling his thumbs.

But seriously, that would be cool on Undercooked or even Jump Scare.

I would love to hear a creepypasta debate between you two with David as the mediator. Just pick a story that one of you likes and the other hates and go all out on each other. Make a pact without David's knowledge and just completely blast the shit out of each other while David just sits their twiddling his thumbs.

But seriously, that would be cool on Undercooked or even Jump Scare.

See, Slimy? The fans want to see you two talk about Candle Cove. XD

Wait, who is crazy enough not to like Candle Cove?

Anyway Ben Drowned would be cool for an undercooked.

Combine your creativity with Slimebeast and Dead Palette, have all three of you come up with something absolutely terrifying, accidentally create The King In Yellow, the actual play, not the short story collection.

Jokes aside I think a joint effort between the three of you could be interesting. Though of course slimy terror and creepy banality may be difficult ingredients to mix in a satisfying way...

Well, I mean, there could be a mixmaster somewhere in the middle, just saying. 

And I'm saving Ben Drowned analysis for something big. Trust me, as one of the initial pieces of Creepypasta I discovered, I want to do analysis of it justice, whether that analysis is favorable or not.

I expect nothing less than a Ben Drowned Live Action Movie. 

JK.

Well, I mean, there could be a mixmaster somewhere in the middle, just saying. 

And I'm saving Ben Drowned analysis for something big. Trust me, as one of the initial pieces of Creepypasta I discovered, I want to do analysis of it justice, whether that analysis is favorable or not.

Of course, you could make it work, you know what you are doing. Or at least you are fantastic at pretending to know what you are doing XD ... now I really want to hear this theoretical Slimepalette story...

I expect nothing less than a Ben Drowned Live Action Movie. 

JK.

A trilogy, each film three hours long, starring David as the Elegy Statue, Kaela as Link, Dead Palette as the Happy Mask Salesman and Slimebeast as the main character.

I'm just gonna do this part as King Igos, OK?

You would do a fantastic King Igos, I admit.

Man, I really wish I knew what you all are talking about so I could contribute to this. Sadly, I was always a book kid.

Man, I really wish I knew what you all are talking about so I could contribute to this. Sadly, I was always a book kid.

As a person who prefers reading to listening to stories: Midnight Marinara are fantastic. I am personally not very fond of Tulpa, their adaptation made it great. They are not straight up readings, but radio plays. They breath new life in things.

Yes David I know you can see this, just bask in the praise for a minute

Dead Palette is great too. Really, listen to both of them.


Oh yeah I just listened to The Normal Porn For Normal People Undercooked. I dont have a youtube account anymore (I misplaced my password and just... whatever) so I'll just leave stuff here.

1. I swear by the great old ones that the first time I read normal porn it did not end in "The site keeps getting taken down", but "Oh by the way heres the link" I didnt click it, I wasnt stupid.

2. Your evil laugh is more terrifying without the echo. Have you practiced evil laughing?

3. I am sure DP has a script for his stories somewhere, otherwise you could play it and pause whenever someone wants to say something.

Yes David I know you can see this, just bask in the praise for a minute

Trust me, I'm basking. Thank you. 

I really do love Midnight Marinara. I just have a bad habit of staying up till midnight listening to BNWYDSE so I can listen to it at midnight. I usually have at least three episodes at a time on my crap nano. I think my favorite adaptation would be the devils game.

Give us some suggestions for stories to look at, either for Midnight Marinara or to be put to scrutiny via Undercooked Analysis.

I recently read the creepypasta "April 12th Mind Story" and it was pretty great. I'll recommend it to you in case you get tired of sifting through the wiki looking for good creepypastas to use. I even posted the story here on toospooky.com. Hope you like it!